Burt Lancaster Truly Hated Lee Marvin—Now We Know the Reason Why
The rivalry between Burt Lancaster and Lee Marvin during the filming of “The Professionals” (1966) was legendary, but the true source of their animosity remained hidden for decades. Now, with the revelation of a secret from Lancaster’s military medical file, the psychology behind their feud finally comes into focus—a clash not just of personalities, but of what it means to be “real.”
On Christmas Eve 1965, in the brutal heat of Death Valley, the simmering tension between the two stars erupted. As a young camera assistant, I witnessed the confrontation that would end their professional relationship forever.
It wasn’t about ego, alcohol, or even professionalism, but about authenticity—the deep need, especially among men of their generation, to prove they were the real thing.
**Burt Lancaster:** Born in East Harlem in 1913, Lancaster grew up poor but determined to build himself into something extraordinary. He became famous for his discipline—5 a.m. workouts, strict routines, and a relentless pursuit of physical perfection.
He treated his body like a cathedral, constructed stone by stone, and by the time he reached Hollywood, he was admired and feared for his self-control. Yet, all this discipline masked a deeper insecurity, something he never admitted even to himself.
**Lee Marvin:** Eleven years younger, Marvin was a decorated Marine who’d survived the horrors of Saipan in World War II. Wounded in battle, he carried both physical and psychological scars. Marvin was chaotic, unpredictable, and authentic in a way that made his performances magnetic.
His drinking was less a vice than a way to cope with memories of war—of friends dying and trauma that never left him. On set, Marvin was often late and frequently drunk, but when the cameras rolled, his truth was undeniable.
The tension between Lancaster’s control and Marvin’s chaos grew throughout filming. Lancaster saw Marvin’s lack of discipline as a threat to the production, while Marvin viewed Lancaster’s perfectionism as inauthentic—a circus act compared to the real suffering he’d endured. The turning point came when Marvin, drunk and bitter, publicly mocked Lancaster for being a “circus performer” who played at being tough without ever facing real danger. Marvin’s war experience became his badge of authenticity, while Lancaster’s discipline was dismissed as mere performance.
Lancaster confronted Marvin, admitting he hadn’t fought in the war but had built everything through sheer will. Marvin shot back that real strength came from surviving trauma, not self-improvement. The confrontation ended their collaboration; they finished the film but never spoke again.
Decades later, a forgotten military file revealed the truth: Lancaster had tried to enlist in combat units multiple times but was rejected due to flat feet from his circus days. All his discipline was penance for not being allowed to prove himself in war. Marvin, meanwhile, was trapped by his trauma, wondering if his authenticity was all he had.
Both men were haunted by what they lacked, each seeing in the other the thing they feared most about themselves. Lancaster envied Marvin’s authenticity; Marvin envied Lancaster’s success built on discipline rather than suffering. The tragedy was not their hatred, but the fact that both missed the truth: realness isn’t earned through suffering or perfection—it’s simply lived.
Their rivalry is a cautionary tale about the stories we tell ourselves to feel worthy. Lancaster and Marvin never made peace, but their struggle remains a powerful lesson: you’re already real. You always were.
—
