The Tragic Life & End of the Four Tops Members: A Story of Talent, Fame, and Heartbreak
The Four Tops are celebrated as one of Motown’s greatest acts, known for timeless hits like “Reach Out I’ll Be There” and “I Can’t Help Myself.” But behind the joy their music brought to millions, the group’s journey was marked by struggle, loss, and tragedy.
Formed in Detroit while still in high school, the original members—Levi Stubs, Abdul “Duke” Fakir, Lawrence Payton, and Renaldo “Obie” Benson—started out performing at local parties.
Their chemistry was immediate and magical, and with help from songwriter Roquel Davis, they landed their first record deal. After several years of struggling for a hit, they joined Motown, where Barry Gordy and the legendary team Holland-Dozier-Holland helped them find success. Their 1964 single “Baby I Need Your Loving” was their first major hit, followed by a string of classics that made them international stars.
Their rivalry with fellow Motown group The Temptations became legendary, often playing out on stage in friendly competition. But while both groups had enduring legacies, the Four Tops faced unique challenges.
As Motown evolved and moved to Los Angeles, older acts like the Four Tops were pushed aside. They left Motown for ABC Dunhill, scoring hits like “Keeper of the Castle” and “Ain’t No Woman (Like the One I’ve Got),” but the chart success slowed in the late ’70s.
The group’s lineup changed over time, but tragedy struck hardest with the deaths of its original members. Lawrence Payton, the group’s vocal arranger and harmony genius, died of liver cancer in 1997 after 43 years with the group.
Renaldo Benson, who co-wrote Marvin Gaye’s “What’s Going On,” lost his leg to poor circulation and later died of lung cancer in 2005. Levi Stubs, whose powerful tenor defined the Four Tops’ sound, battled cancer and suffered a stroke in 2000, passing away in 2008. Each loss deeply affected the group and their fans.
As the years went on, only Duke Fakir remained from the original lineup, determined to keep the Four Tops’ legacy alive. He continued performing well into his eighties, becoming an advocate for older artists who struggled to receive fair royalties for their music.
Fakir spoke out about the injustice faced by musicians whose pre-1972 recordings aren’t compensated by digital radio platforms—a fight that continues today with legislation like the Classics Act.
Newer members joined the group, including Alexander Morris, who faced his own tragedy in 2023. After seeking emergency care for chest pain, he was mistaken for a mentally ill patient when he told hospital staff he was a Four Tops singer.
He was restrained and given a psychological evaluation before being believed, leading to a lawsuit for racial discrimination.
Despite the heartbreak and hardships, the Four Tops’ legacy endures. Their music remains a cornerstone of R&B, pop, and soul, inspiring generations of artists and listeners. Inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame and honored with lifetime achievement awards, the Four Tops are remembered not just for their harmonies and hits, but for their resilience in the face of adversity.
Their story is a reminder that behind every legendary song are real people—men who faced the highs and lows of fame, fought for fairness, and ultimately left an indelible mark on music history.
—
